Friday, August 17, 2007

Archieve.org မွ BBC နာရီ၀က္ျကိဳတင္ သတင္းထုတ္လႊင့္ေျကာင္း အတည္ျပဳ

အင္တာနက္မွတ္တမ္း ဗီဒီယုိ၊ ဓါတ္ပုံမ်ား သိမ္းဆည္းထားသည့္ Archieve.org မွ ညႊန္ျကားေရးမွဳး Stewart Cheifet မွ BBC သတင္းဌာန နာရီ၀က္တင္ျကိဳျပီး Bunker အျဖစ္ခုိင္မာစြာ တည္ေဆာက္ထားသည့္ တုိက္ျကီး ျပိဳက်မွဳ ထုတ္လႊင့္ေျကာင္း ေထာက္ခံေပး လုိက္ပါသည္။ ထူးဆန္းသည္မွ BBC, CNN , FOX News တုိ႔မွ အခုလုိ ေထာက္ခံစာထြက္လာခ်င္းကုိ သတင္းအျဖစ္ မေျကျငာခဲ့ပါ။ နည္းနည္းေတာ့ ထူးဆန္းေနပါသည္။

အျပည့္အစုံကုိ မူရင္းအတုိင္းဖတ္ႏုိင္ပါသည္။
I am Director of Collections at the Internet Archive, responsible for all video and audio files.

This video clip is part of a collection from the TV Archive of global television coverage of the events that occurred on and shortly after September 11, 2001.

This clip, among others, has drawn quite a bit of attention because it appears to show a BBC reporter in New York reporting that World Trade Center Building 7, also referred to as WTC7 or the Salomon Brothers Building, has collapsed before it actually did collapse.

Despite some confusion on the issue of time code stamping and UTC conversions to EDT, the timing on the clip appears to be correct. This particular clip was recorded between 4:54 and 5:36 PM EDT. The anchor references to the WTC7 collapsing occur at 4:58 PM and 5:01 PM and then a live reporter says the building has collapsed at 5:08 PM in what appears to be a live shot with the building still in tact behind her. The feed from the live reporter is lost at 5:15 PM and then the building does actually collapse at 5:20 PM.

A subsequent clip from the BBC then shows coverage of the actual collapse in an archived account recorded from 5:36 – 6:16PM. This clip is available at http://www.archive.org/details/bbc200109111736-1818 .

An annotated version of the key sequence from this clip can be seen at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LzxEoEfE_8A .

Further support for the correct timing on the clip comes from another archived clip, this one from the BBC 24 channel which includes a time stamp on the TV screen indicating that the reference to the collapses of WTC7 does occur before the actual collapse.

There is some discussion as to whether or not that time stamp was later edited in by someone tampering with the clip. It is unclear whether that happened or not but the reporting and the time of the reporting as shown does seem to coincide with the other BBC World report. This clip can be seen at various web sites including http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/february2007/280207timestamp.htm .

Also there has been some discussion about whether the shot of the WTC7 still standing was a live shot or a so-called “green screen” shot in which the live reporter was photographed in front of an electronic screen with a superimposed image of videotape of earlier coverage. That could explain the time disparity; however other clips seem to support the view that the video behind the BBC reporter in this clip is indeed live.

This clip is being widely circulated on the web along with other 9/11 news coverage clips that have surfaced. The earliest apparent reports of WTC7 collapsing come from CNN which reports before 5PM that WTC7 is either burning, is collapsing or has collapsed. You can see this clip at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD0UWq_ORR4 . That story then gets repeated later on BBC 24 and BBC World. Similar coverage on ABC can be found posted at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Qyiov_c6Fg .

Assuming all the time references are correct, there are two possible explanations offered for the confusion. One is that the building was intentionally brought down by its owner and that a press release indicating that was prematurely issued and prematurely reported on by the media.

Another explanation is that there was simply confusion at the time and some journalistic “whispering down the lane” in which early stories that there was something happening at WTC7 led to rumors of its collapsing which then led to on-air reporting of its collapse. The fact that the WTC7 is still standing and visible in the background of the live shot appears to confirm that the reporting of the collapse did take place before the actual collapse.

One possible explanation for the apparent clairvoyance of the reporter, or the alleged deception by those in charge, is that there was a fire at WTC7 when it was first reported on CNN at approximately 4:10 PM and that the BBC then picked up that story from CNN and reported that the WTC7 might be collapsing and in the confusion of live news coverage that story then was communicated to the anchor and the reporter that the building had collapsed.

Additional information may be available from other television network coverage of that same period of time which has also been archived by the TV Archive. This includes coverage from ABC, CBS, NBC, FOX, and CNN. Efforts are underway to gather that additional archive footage so that a more comprehensive picture can be presented of what really happened that day.

Other references and discussions related to this clip can be found at various other web sites including http://www.livelead.com , http://www.911truth.org , http://www.prisonplanet.com , http://www.informationliberation.com , http://www.911blogger.com , and http://www.digg.com .

The official BBC statement regarding its explanation for the mistaken reporting can be found at http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/theeditors/2007/02/27/index.html .

Added March 4, 2007 at 9:13 AM PST.
The BBC has now posted new information in an effort to explain the apparent errors in this report. It is available at
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/theeditors/2007/03/part_of_the_conspiracy_2.html .

ကုိးကားခ်က္
http://www.archive.org/details/bbc200109111654-1736
(ယုံျကည္ခ်က္။ ။ ဒီမုိကေရစီ၊ လူအခြင့္အေရးဆုိတာ စာရြက္ေပၚမွာပဲရွိပါတယ္။ ဗုဒၶတရားေတာ္နဲ႔ အညီ ေလာဘ၊ ေဒါသ၊ ေမာဟ နည္းေအာင္ လုပ္ခ်င္းသည္သာ လက္ေတြ႔က်ေသာ ျငိမ္းခ်မ္းေရးစံနစ္ျဖစ္ေပၚ လာေစမည္ျဖစ္ပါသည္။)

1 comment:

Jack said...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7_World_Trade_Center